Skip to content

Applebee's Best Pasta, Explained: What Each Dish Is Actually Like and Which One to Order

Applebee's Best Pasta, Explained: What Each Dish Is Actually Like and Which One to Order
Short answer: Order the Three-Cheese Chicken Penne ($17.49, 1,350 calories) if you want the best all-round pasta: it is tied for the cheapest pasta entrée here, the second-highest in protein at 77 grams (the Classic Broccoli Chicken Alfredo has 79g), and the only pasta on this page that also appears as a premium entrée on the 2 for $25 deal (with a $2.50 upcharge, per our upcharge guide). Order the Classic Broccoli Chicken Alfredo ($17.99, 1,440 calories) if you want the classic, long-running best-seller. Order the Four Cheese Mac & Cheese with Honey Pepper Chicken ($17.49, 1,360 calories) if you want the most indulgent plate. Four more pastas joined the page on November 17, 2026 — the Breadsticks with Alfredo Sauce ($7.99, 1,510 calories), the cheapest pasta here and the best calories-per-dollar on the whole menu, the Classic Blackened Shrimp Alfredo ($19.49, 1,320 calories), the lightest pasta here, and two Andouille pennes ($19.99 and $20.49). Every price below is this guide's listed menu price — Applebee's is franchised, so your restaurant's price can differ, and independent trackers currently list higher local prices for the same dishes. Checked November 21, 2026.

Choose in 30 Seconds

Most people do not need a ranking. They need the right pasta for their table, so start here:

Your situationOrder thisWhy
You want the best all-round pastaThree-Cheese Chicken Penne, $17.49Tied cheapest entrée here, 77g protein, and the only pasta with a 2 for $25 route
You want the classicClassic Broccoli Chicken Alfredo, $17.99Grilled chicken, broccoli and fettuccine in rich Alfredo — the long-running best-seller
You want the most indulgent plateFour Cheese Mac & Cheese with Honey Pepper Chicken, $17.49Four-cheese penne, crispy tenders, honey pepper sauce and bacon — the sweetest plate here
You want crunch and marinara, not creamChicken Parmesan Fettuccine, $17.49Breaded chicken cutlet, marinara and melted mozzarella over fettuccine, with a garlic breadstick
You want the lightest pastaClassic Blackened Shrimp Alfredo, $19.491,320 calories — the lightest pasta here, shrimp and Alfredo without the broccoli
You want the cheapest pasta of allBreadsticks with Alfredo Sauce, $7.99Cheapest pasta here and the best calories-per-dollar on the menu — but a shareable side, not an entrée
You want the heaviest plateBourbon Street Chicken & Andouille Sausage Penne, $19.991,590 calories — the heaviest pasta here, chicken and andouille sausage
You are ordering for two on a budgetTwo Penne entrées via 2 for $25, plus $2.50 upcharge eachThe deal route beats two full-price pastas by a wide margin — see the value section below

Every Pasta, With the Numbers That Actually Matter

The figures below are the listed figures from our pasta menu. Protein, fat and sugar are quoted only where our nutrition chart publishes them for that exact dish; the Chicken Parmesan has no exact nutrition row there, so no macros are quoted for it. Read the honest note on figures below before comparing these prices with other sites — several trackers quote higher local prices for the same dishes.

PastaPriceCaloriesWhat stands out
Three-Cheese Chicken Penne$17.491,350Tied cheapest entrée; 77g protein; 2 for $25 premium entrée
Classic Broccoli Chicken Alfredo$17.991,440Fourth-heaviest calories; 79g protein, the most of any pasta; classic best-seller
Four Cheese Mac & Cheese with Honey Pepper Chicken$17.491,360Tied cheapest entrée of the original four; 44g sugars; 3,300mg sodium
Chicken Parmesan Fettuccine$17.491,410Marinara, not Alfredo; on the 2 for $25
Classic Blackened Shrimp Alfredo$19.491,320Lightest calories; shrimp Alfredo, no broccoli
Blackened Shrimp & Andouille Sausage Penne$20.491,470Priciest; featured item; shrimp + andouille
Breadsticks with Alfredo Sauce$7.991,510Cheapest; best calories-per-dollar on the menu; shareable side
Bourbon Street Chicken & Andouille Sausage Penne$19.991,590Heaviest calories; chicken + andouille

Two things jump out. First, the pasta menu now spans $12.50 ($7.99 to $20.49), and the gap is almost all at the top: the four original pastas still sit within $0.50 of each other, while three of the four new ones run $19.49 to $20.49 — and the Breadsticks undercut the whole page at $7.99. Second, every pasta here is a 1,300-plus-calorie plate, so there is no light option on this page; the lightest, the Classic Blackened Shrimp Alfredo at 1,320, is still a full, rich meal, and the gap to the heaviest, the Bourbon Street Chicken & Andouille Sausage Penne at 1,590, is 270 calories.

1. Three-Cheese Chicken Penne: The Best All-Round Order

What you get: penne tossed in Asiago, Parmesan and white Cheddar cream sauce, topped with grilled chicken breast and fresh bruschetta tomatoes, $17.49, at 1,350 calories. Our nutrition chart puts it at 71g fat, 40g saturated fat, 2,720mg sodium and 77g protein — the third-highest protein figure on the whole menu — with milk, wheat and soy allergens.

How it eats: creamy without being one-note: the three cheeses give the sauce depth, the grilled chicken keeps it a proper entrée rather than a side of pasta, and the bruschetta tomatoes cut through the richness. It is the most balanced plate here — rich, but with fresh and grilled elements doing real work, not just garnish.

Why it ranks first: it wins on three axes at once. It is tied for the cheapest pasta entrée, it is the second-lightest pasta on the page, and it is the only pasta here with a deal route: our 2 for $25 upcharge guide lists the Three-Cheese Chicken Penne as a premium entrée at a commonly charged $2.50 upcharge (verify locally), so two people can eat it as part of the deal for far less than two full-price plates.

Skip it if: you want a classic Alfredo flavour rather than a three-cheese cream sauce, you dislike tomatoes in a hot pasta, or you want the crunch of breaded chicken — that is the Chicken Parmesan below.

2. Classic Broccoli Chicken Alfredo: The Classic, and the Safe Second Pick

What you get: grilled chicken over fettuccine tossed with broccoli florets and rich Alfredo sauce, finished with shaved Parmesan cheese, $17.99, at 1,440 calories — the fourth-heaviest pasta here.

How it eats: like the pasta most people picture when they say Alfredo — smooth, buttery, generous, with broccoli giving each bite something green and a little bite against the sauce. One independent 2026 pasta guide calls it the long-running best-seller, and that rings true: it is the least surprising dish on this page, in a good way.

One honest counterpoint: our nutrition chart now publishes the full panel, transcribed from Applebee's own Interactive Nutrition Menu on 17 November 2026: 79g fat, 45g saturated fat, 2,860mg sodium, 107g carbohydrates and 79g protein, with milk, wheat and soy allergens — the second-most protein of any dish on the menu, and the fourth-best protein-per-dollar at 4.39 g/$. Trackers disagree on its calories, quoting 1,270 to 1,440 for the same dish. Our 1,440 follows Applebee's own Interactive Nutrition Menu, which lists the grilled-chicken build at 1,440 calories with 79g of protein, and five trackers agree on 1,440; the 1,270–1,410 figures are an older calculator snapshot. Treat the spread as a reminder that portions and preparation vary by restaurant.

Skip it if: you dislike broccoli, you want a sweeter or spicier plate, or you are watching saturated fat — at 45g, more than twice the Daily Value, this is the richest plate on the page.

3. Four Cheese Mac & Cheese with Honey Pepper Chicken: The Maximalist Pick

What you get: four-cheese penne mac and cheese topped with crispy chicken tenders tossed in honey pepper sauce and Applewood-smoked bacon, $17.49, at 1,360 calories. Our nutrition chart puts it at 55g fat, 3,300mg sodium, 160g carbohydrates, 44g sugars and 55g protein, with milk, wheat and soy allergens.

How it eats: sweet, salty, crispy and creamy all at once — the honey pepper tenders are the point, and the mac and cheese underneath is a rich base rather than the star. It is the most fun plate here and the least restrained: 44 grams of sugars is by far the highest sugar figure on this page, and 3,300mg of sodium is the highest sodium figure too.

Order it smarter: come hungry, and do not pair it with a sugary drink or a sweet appetiser — the honey pepper sauce already supplies the sweetness for the whole meal. It is tied with the Chicken Parmesan and the Penne at $17.49 — the Alfredo now runs $0.50 higher — so it is no longer the priciest of the four original pastas, though it is still the best candidate for sharing a taste rather than eating a whole plate alone.

Skip it if: you dislike sweet-savoury combinations, you are watching sodium or sugar, or you want a classic pasta flavour — this is a chicken-tender dish that happens to sit on mac and cheese.

4. Chicken Parmesan Fettuccine: The Crunch Pick

What you get: a crispy breaded chicken cutlet topped with warm marinara and melted mozzarella, served over fettuccine with a garlic breadstick, $17.49, at 1,410 calories — the fourth-lightest pasta here.

How it eats: like the Italian-American classic it is: crunchy cutlet, tangy marinara, melted cheese pulling over fettuccine, and a breadstick for the leftover sauce. It is the only pasta here built on marinara rather than a cream or cheese sauce, which makes it the right pick when every other pasta on the page feels too rich — even though, at 1,410 calories, it is still the fourth-lightest of the eight.

The honest limit: no exact nutrition row for this dish is published in our nutrition chart, so no fat, sugar or protein figure is quoted for it here. Applebee's own Interactive Nutrition Menu lists the pasta at 1,230 calories without the breadstick, and its menu tile lists 1,410 with it; seven trackers agree on 1,410, against 1,320 on one. Our 1,410 is the plate as served, with the garlic breadstick. It is also the only pasta here where the crunch — the cutlet's whole appeal — softens fast on a takeout or delivery journey, so order it dine-in when you can.

Skip it if: you want a cream sauce, you dislike marinara or breaded chicken, or you want the lightest pasta — the Classic Blackened Shrimp Alfredo is 90 calories lighter, though $2.00 more.

5. Classic Blackened Shrimp Alfredo: The Lightest Pasta Here

What you get: penne in creamy Alfredo sauce with blackened shrimp, Parmesan cheese, tomato and green onion, $19.49, at 1,320 calories — the lightest pasta on the page.

How it eats: like the chicken Alfredo's leaner cousin: the same creamy sauce, but the blackened shrimp brings spice and a firmer bite than grilled chicken, and the tomato and green onion cut the richness. It is the only pasta here where the protein is seafood, which is the point — order it for the shrimp, not for a bargain.

The honest limit: no exact nutrition row for this dish is published in our nutrition chart, so no fat, sugar or protein figure is quoted for it here. Applebee's own Interactive Nutrition Menu carries no row under this exact name (checked 17 November 2026) — its "Classic Broccoli Alfredo (with Blackened Shrimp)" row at 1,320 calories is a different name and is not substituted — and the official menu tile lists $19.49 / 1,320, the tile description naming no broccoli, so our listing follows the tile. At $19.49 it is the second-priciest pasta here, so the lightest plate is not the cheapest one.

Skip it if: you dislike shrimp, you want broccoli in your Alfredo — that is the chicken version above — or you are watching the bill: the Penne is $2.00 less and only 30 calories heavier.

6. Blackened Shrimp & Andouille Sausage Penne: The Priciest Plate

What you get: penne with blackened shrimp and andouille sausage, $20.49, at 1,470 calories — the priciest pasta on the page, and a featured item on the menu.

How it eats: smoky and spicy rather than creamy: the andouille brings heat and chew, the blackened shrimp brings char, and the penne holds both. It is the boldest plate here, and the one most likely to divide a table — the sausage is the flavour, not a garnish.

The honest limit: no exact nutrition row for this dish is published in our nutrition chart, so no fat, sugar or protein figure is quoted for it here. Applebee's own Interactive Nutrition Menu carries no "Andouille" row at all (checked 17 November 2026) — its "Bourbon Street Shrimp & Sausage Penne" row at 1,290 calories is a different name and is not substituted — and the official menu tile lists $20.49 / 1,470 for the Andouille name, the tile being the plate as served, so our 1,470 follows the tile.

Skip it if: you dislike spicy sausage, you want a cream sauce, or you are ordering on a budget — it is $3.00 more than the Penne for 120 more calories.

7. Breadsticks with Alfredo Sauce: The Cheapest Pasta — and the Best Value on the Menu

What you get: warm breadsticks served with creamy Alfredo sauce for dipping, $7.99, at 1,510 calories — the cheapest pasta on the page by a wide margin, and the second-heaviest.

How it eats: like a starter that forgot it was a side: soft breadsticks, warm sauce, nothing to assemble and nothing to cut. It is the only pasta here built for sharing, and the only one where the price makes it an add-on rather than a main — order it for the table, not as your dinner.

The honest limit: do not mistake cheap for light. At 1,510 calories it is the second-heaviest pasta here, and at $0.53 per 100 calories it is the best calories-per-dollar on the whole menu — which is a value figure, not a health claim. Our nutrition chart now publishes the full panel, transcribed from Applebee's own Interactive Nutrition Menu on 17 November 2026: 90g fat, 43g saturated fat, 2,570mg sodium, 139g carbohydrates and 38g protein, with milk, wheat and soy allergens — and at 38g of protein for $7.99 it is the second-best protein-per-dollar on the whole menu (4.76 g/$), behind Applebee's Riblets.

Skip it if: you want a proper entrée — the Penne is tied for the cheapest of those at $17.49 — or you want the lightest pasta: the Blackened Shrimp Alfredo is 190 calories lighter, though $11.50 more.

8. Bourbon Street Chicken & Andouille Sausage Penne: The Heaviest Plate

What you get: penne tossed with chicken and andouille sausage in Applebee's Bourbon Street style, $19.99, at 1,590 calories — the heaviest pasta on the page.

How it eats: like the Bourbon Street Steak's pasta cousin: savoury, a little sweet, a little heat from the andouille, with the chicken keeping it a proper entrée rather than a sausage plate. It is the most filling pasta here by 80 calories, so come hungry or plan to share.

The honest limit: no exact nutrition row for this dish is published in our nutrition chart, so no fat, sugar or protein figure is quoted for it here. Applebee's own Interactive Nutrition Menu carries no "Andouille" row at all (checked 17 November 2026) — its "Bourbon Street Chicken & Sausage Penne" row at 1,410 calories is a different name and is not substituted — and the official menu tile lists $19.99 / 1,590 for the Andouille name, the tile being the plate as served, so our 1,590 follows the tile.

Skip it if: you dislike sausage, you want the lightest pasta — the Blackened Shrimp Alfredo is 270 calories lighter — or you are ordering on a budget: the Penne is $2.50 less and 240 calories lighter.

Getting the Best Value on Pasta Night

The cheapest route to pasta is the deal route, not a discount on a single plate. The Three-Cheese Chicken Penne is a premium entrée on the 2 for $25 deal at a $2.50 upcharge, so two Penne entrées plus a shared appetiser cost $25 plus two upcharges — $30 in total where both $2.50 upcharges apply — against $34.98 for two full-price Penne plates alone, and the deal adds the appetiser on top. For the full deal picture, see our specials and deals page and our 2 for $25 upcharge guide before ordering. Outside the deal, the value order is simple: the Breadsticks are the cheapest at $7.99 — and the best calories-per-dollar on the whole menu at $0.53 per 100 calories — the Penne, the Mac & Cheese and the Chicken Parmesan tie as the cheapest entrées at $17.49, and the Alfredo is $0.50 more at $17.99; the Blackened Shrimp Alfredo and the two Andouille pennes run $19.49 to $20.49, so among the entrées the gaps are still small — let taste, not price, decide between them. And if pasta is only the end of a larger order, our best chicken guide and best steaks guide cover the other mains. If you want something lighter alongside the pasta, our best salads guide ranks all seven salads — three of them are flat entrées on the 2 for $25 deal.

An Honest Note on Figures

Applebee's does not publish one national price list — its restaurants are franchised, and location menus show the Penne from $14.99 to $27.49 across 916 restaurants on one tracker (checked 18 November 2026), against our listed $17.49, and the Alfredo from $15.99 to $19.39 across trackers, against our listed $17.99. One 2026 guide puts the Penne at $17–$20 and the Alfredo at $17–$21 as typical US ranges. The prices in this guide are our listed menu prices, and your restaurant's price can differ in either direction. Calories follow the same pattern: the Penne is quoted at 1,170 to 1,350 calories by trackers against our 1,350, the Alfredo at 1,270 to 1,440 against our 1,440, and the Fettuccine at 1,320 to 1,410 against our 1,410, so compare like with like and expect small preparation differences. The four pastas added November 17, 2026 are listed from Applebee's own ordering menu at the Chicago Grand Avenue restaurant, read live that day — Breadsticks with Alfredo Sauce $7.99 / 1,510 calories, Bourbon Street Chicken & Andouille Sausage Penne $19.99 / 1,590, Blackened Shrimp & Andouille Sausage Penne $20.49 / 1,470, Classic Blackened Shrimp Alfredo $19.49 / 1,320 — and the mirror's older short names for the Andouille pennes (1,410 and 1,290 calories) are not the figures we publish; the official tiles are the plates as served. The Breadsticks' full nutrition panel is now published in our nutrition chart (90g fat, 2,570mg sodium, 38g protein, milk/wheat/soy), transcribed from Applebee's own Interactive Nutrition Menu on 17 November 2026; the other three new pastas still have no panel under their exact names in that tool, so no macros are quoted for them. The Classic Broccoli Chicken Alfredo's full panel is now published too (79g fat, 45g saturated fat, 2,860mg sodium, 79g protein, milk/wheat/soy), transcribed from the same tool on 17 November 2026; the Chicken Parmesan Fettuccine still has none — the tool's panel for it is the 1,230-calorie build without the breadstick, not the 1,410 plate as served.

You May See Elsewhere: Pastas Not Ranked Here

Applebee's own nutrition menu still lists pasta rows under shorter names — "Bourbon Street Chicken & Sausage Penne" at 1,410 calories, "Bourbon Street Shrimp & Sausage Penne" at 1,290 and "Classic Broccoli Alfredo (with Blackened Shrimp)" at 1,320. Checked 17 November 2026, the tool carries no row under the exact Andouille or Blackened Shrimp Alfredo names, and no "Andouille" match at all — so those shorter-name figures are not published here as the dishes' figures, and the official tiles ($19.99 / 1,590, $20.49 / 1,470 and $19.49 / 1,320) are the plates as served. If a location menu shows another pasta we do not list, ask about it by name; if it lands on our pasta page, this ranking will be updated.

Methodology: How This Ranking Was Built

Prices and calories are taken from our own menu and nutrition data, cross-checked November 19, 2026 against Applebee's own Interactive Nutrition Menu and five independent trackers (usafoodjournal November 15, applebeesmenuss October 27, applebeesmenuprices September, applebeesmenuguide October, applemenuhub) plus delivery-menu listings for the local-price spread, and against Applebee's own ordering menu at the Chicago Grand Avenue restaurant, read live November 17, 2026, which supplied the four new pastas, and re-read live November 19, 2026. Taste judgements follow those published sources and the dishes' own descriptions, not our own kitchen: where sources disagreed, both views are reported. Dishes are ranked by overall recommendation — distinctiveness, flavour, balance, value and the deal route — not by price or calories alone, which is why the cheapest entrée sits first and the crunch pick sits fourth. For allergen details, see our allergen guide.

Muhammad Suheer
Founder & EditorMuhammad Suheer

Muhammad Suheer is the founder and editor of Applebees Menu Guide, where he builds and runs independent restaurant-menu guides. He checks prices against Applebee's official ordering pages and published nutrition documents, and he maintains the price, calorie and allergen tables published on this site. About us